A
Anonymous
Guest
-
Help Support UKworkshop.co.uk:
Mcluma
Established Member
I bought on friday the bosch GSB20-2rce for about 140 from powertools UK this is currently the best corded drill about
this is a very good allround hammerdrill, for all jobs arround the house, with constant electronic controll, so always the right torx
You just cannot have all cordless tools, (i know as I have about 4 18v cordless drill :wink: )
McLuma
this is a very good allround hammerdrill, for all jobs arround the house, with constant electronic controll, so always the right torx
You just cannot have all cordless tools, (i know as I have about 4 18v cordless drill :wink: )
McLuma
Paul Chapman
Established Member
Hi Dave,
I have a Kango SDS (hammer drilling only) which is a fabulous drill which I use for most masonry drilling; an enormous and quite heavy B&Q SDS which does drilling, hammer drilling, or hammer only which is useful for some DIY jobs; and an ordinary B&Q two speed drill for woodwork and drill stand use. Got all three for under £200.
If you were to buy only an SDS drill you would need an additional chuck, which is fitted via an adaptor into the SDS chuck, to take ordinary drills. This might make the physical length of the drill too long and unwieldly for many jobs and it would probably be far too long for drill stand work.
Quite good drills seem to be available for far less than £200 and I think you really need more than one to suit different types of work.
If you decide to buy an ordinary drill as well as the SDS, my advice would be to stay away from keyless chucks. In my experience they do not grip well enough and can easily ruin drill bits. Change it for a keyed one.
Hope this helps
Paul
I have a Kango SDS (hammer drilling only) which is a fabulous drill which I use for most masonry drilling; an enormous and quite heavy B&Q SDS which does drilling, hammer drilling, or hammer only which is useful for some DIY jobs; and an ordinary B&Q two speed drill for woodwork and drill stand use. Got all three for under £200.
If you were to buy only an SDS drill you would need an additional chuck, which is fitted via an adaptor into the SDS chuck, to take ordinary drills. This might make the physical length of the drill too long and unwieldly for many jobs and it would probably be far too long for drill stand work.
Quite good drills seem to be available for far less than £200 and I think you really need more than one to suit different types of work.
If you decide to buy an ordinary drill as well as the SDS, my advice would be to stay away from keyless chucks. In my experience they do not grip well enough and can easily ruin drill bits. Change it for a keyed one.
Hope this helps
Paul
Christian A.
Established Member
davejester":30deon5s said:
That mostly depends on what exactly you are going to use it for. The most versatile "drill" is a so-called Multihammer", such as the Metabo UHE 22.
This tool offers:
- rotary hammer mode
- chiselling action (not for heavy-duty demolitions)
- "common" drilling action, two speed gear unit
- interchangeable chuck (no need for an adapter and an extra chuck)
Drills that offer similar versatility are made by Kress and AEG.
The Hilti TE 2 M lacks the chiselling mode.
As far as I know, most (all) other SDS Plus rotary hammer drills (for example, Bosch, Makita, Hitachi etc.) are not equipped with a two speed gear unit. As a consequence of their rather low rpm, they are hardly suitable for drilling small dia holes in wood and steel.
Hope this helps,
Christian
A
Anonymous
Guest
-
Newbie_Neil
Established Member
filsgreen
Established Member
Paul Chapman
Established Member
Hi again Dave,
I wonder if you are looking at the right sort of tool for the work you have in mind. If you are planning to do lots of chasing walls for electrics, plumbing, etc would you be better off hiring a wall chaser for that work (see the Screwfix link in Neil's post above - they have several)? It would probably produce a far neater result than the demolition hammer approach you seem to have in mind.
Paul
I wonder if you are looking at the right sort of tool for the work you have in mind. If you are planning to do lots of chasing walls for electrics, plumbing, etc would you be better off hiring a wall chaser for that work (see the Screwfix link in Neil's post above - they have several)? It would probably produce a far neater result than the demolition hammer approach you seem to have in mind.
Paul
OLD
Established Member
sds is very good it drills quickly with lots of hammer and will blow the front face of a brick if you are to heavy with it. i use the low cost £40 screwfix also good for demo. & chasing between diamond 'discings'
So consider the above drill + small angle grinder and d/discs and a medium range pistol drill with hammer for holes in wood and the smaller masonry drilling.
So consider the above drill + small angle grinder and d/discs and a medium range pistol drill with hammer for holes in wood and the smaller masonry drilling.
A
Anonymous
Guest
I have been wondering whether I'm really doing this the right way round. I thought SDS because drilling holes is so tough in our walls. This could just be the rubbish drill I've been using though. I also thought sds due to the slower speed being more suitable for the auger bit. I didn't realise you could get impact/hammer drills with two gears (which hence solves the auger problem).
Sounds like I need a decent hammer/impact drill for now. I can think about the SDS when I really need it.
Dave
Sounds like I need a decent hammer/impact drill for now. I can think about the SDS when I really need it.
Dave
Paul Chapman
Established Member
Dave,
I would still go for an SDS drill - ordinary hammer drills are no comparison when you try to drill through concrete lintels, etc to put up curtain rails for example. But you could get a good one plus a good two speed ordinary drill (with or without hammer action) for your woodwork for far less than the £200 you were originally thinking of paying.
Paul
I would still go for an SDS drill - ordinary hammer drills are no comparison when you try to drill through concrete lintels, etc to put up curtain rails for example. But you could get a good one plus a good two speed ordinary drill (with or without hammer action) for your woodwork for far less than the £200 you were originally thinking of paying.
Paul
syntec4
Established Member
Newbie_Neil":2h4rt253 said:
I have had this one for around 5 years so far. No Problems at all. Plenty of power, been dropped, stood on etc. never lets me down. I have a Chuck adapter with it so I can use ordinary bits too. Very Good Value at that price.
Lee.
Christian A.
Established Member
Hi,
if the Metabo Multihammers are out of your budget you might want to have a look at the Kress Multihammer HMX 26. It isn’t equipped with the same interchangeable chuck feature the Metabo uses.
If the two speed gear box is not important to you, you can choose from a rather wide range of tools. My recommendation is to look for a SDS rotary hammer drill with a chuck change technology similar to the one the Bosch GBH 2-26 DFR offers.
Reason: As far as I know this mechanism is superior to inserting an adapter in the SDS chuck as it’s impossible to eliminate the play within the SDS chuck. Comparable Hammers are the Dewalt D 25103 K, the Dewalt D 25304 K (quite interesting due to the optionally available dust collection), the Makita HR 2450T, the Metabo KHE 26, the Metabo KHE 28 etc.
Hope this helps
Christian
if the Metabo Multihammers are out of your budget you might want to have a look at the Kress Multihammer HMX 26. It isn’t equipped with the same interchangeable chuck feature the Metabo uses.
If the two speed gear box is not important to you, you can choose from a rather wide range of tools. My recommendation is to look for a SDS rotary hammer drill with a chuck change technology similar to the one the Bosch GBH 2-26 DFR offers.
Reason: As far as I know this mechanism is superior to inserting an adapter in the SDS chuck as it’s impossible to eliminate the play within the SDS chuck. Comparable Hammers are the Dewalt D 25103 K, the Dewalt D 25304 K (quite interesting due to the optionally available dust collection), the Makita HR 2450T, the Metabo KHE 26, the Metabo KHE 28 etc.
Hope this helps
Christian
Dave wrote,
Hi Dave. I can personally vouch for the Metabo. I have this one. For build quality and performance, I rate it as the 'Festool' of drills. Excellent speed control, an incredibly good keyless chuck and a very smooth, quiet motor and gearbox. Yes it's pricey but you do get what you pay for - it smacks of quality engineering and will last for donkeys years.
PS. I think the code thingy is a bit gimmicky but I have the earlier model without it.
cheers,
Ike
Hi Dave. I can personally vouch for the Metabo. I have this one. For build quality and performance, I rate it as the 'Festool' of drills. Excellent speed control, an incredibly good keyless chuck and a very smooth, quiet motor and gearbox. Yes it's pricey but you do get what you pay for - it smacks of quality engineering and will last for donkeys years.
PS. I think the code thingy is a bit gimmicky but I have the earlier model without it.
cheers,
Ike
A
Anonymous
Guest
Thanks again for all the info.
I was all set on the bosch GSB 20-2 RE impact/hammer drill. I thought that would leave me with 100quid to spend on an SDS drill when I really need one. Then I saw the RCE model has controllable speed and constant speed; something I think I'll use a lot. Unfortunately it's another 30 quid. That's more than the Metabo SBE 750.
Now I'm back to wondering what to do. Ideally I'd like to make the decision by seeing them all but I don't have any decent shops near me.
SWMBO told me to just buy a drill but hitting that 'BUY-ME' button is proving much more difficult than I expected.
So, is Metabo better than Bosch? The Bosch does look very good.
Dave
I was all set on the bosch GSB 20-2 RE impact/hammer drill. I thought that would leave me with 100quid to spend on an SDS drill when I really need one. Then I saw the RCE model has controllable speed and constant speed; something I think I'll use a lot. Unfortunately it's another 30 quid. That's more than the Metabo SBE 750.
Now I'm back to wondering what to do. Ideally I'd like to make the decision by seeing them all but I don't have any decent shops near me.
SWMBO told me to just buy a drill but hitting that 'BUY-ME' button is proving much more difficult than I expected.
So, is Metabo better than Bosch? The Bosch does look very good.
Dave
A
Anonymous
Guest
Cool, I've just noticed that message took me from being a Forum Newbie to a Woodworker!
Dave
Dave
Hi Dave,
I'd rate Metabo on par with Bosch blue stuff. Both brands would rate trade and some industrial.
Bosch green is light trade/home - OK but not close to Metabo build quality.
<edit> hadn't read your earlier posts thoroughly enough and didn't realise I was banging on about something over the budget - sorry!
cheers,
Ike
I'd rate Metabo on par with Bosch blue stuff. Both brands would rate trade and some industrial.
Bosch green is light trade/home - OK but not close to Metabo build quality.
<edit> hadn't read your earlier posts thoroughly enough and didn't realise I was banging on about something over the budget - sorry!
cheers,
Ike
Quetech
Established Member
Dave
Go for the Metabo sds.
I live in a granite house and the sds is the only drill that will cope
with the drilling the granite.
I have two metabo drills one sds and one normal and would highly recomend them.
I think they are one of the best I have seen on the market.
Check out power tools direct as they have some good deals on
metabo sds drills.
Mike
Go for the Metabo sds.
I live in a granite house and the sds is the only drill that will cope
with the drilling the granite.
I have two metabo drills one sds and one normal and would highly recomend them.
I think they are one of the best I have seen on the market.
Check out power tools direct as they have some good deals on
metabo sds drills.
Mike
RogerS
Established Member
Dave
I've used many different corded drills including the Bosch mentioned earlier. If you are drilling into something REALLY hard than SDS is the only way to go IMHO. It's all there in the specs...the sheer power behind an SDS impact (if you get a big enough one !) knocks spots off the smaller hammer drills. No competition.
if you are chasing in soft wall material (such as thermalite blocks or equivalent) then i recommend SDS plus the channel cutting chisel from Armeg (available from Axminster). Hiring chasers is a good idea but in my experience they generate HUGE amounts of dust.
Roger
I've used many different corded drills including the Bosch mentioned earlier. If you are drilling into something REALLY hard than SDS is the only way to go IMHO. It's all there in the specs...the sheer power behind an SDS impact (if you get a big enough one !) knocks spots off the smaller hammer drills. No competition.
if you are chasing in soft wall material (such as thermalite blocks or equivalent) then i recommend SDS plus the channel cutting chisel from Armeg (available from Axminster). Hiring chasers is a good idea but in my experience they generate HUGE amounts of dust.
Roger
Similar threads
