Re: 2011 December Challenge ( Voting thread )

[Blister]

Hi

We have 12 entrants who can vote as listed below :-

Malinda_dd ( Voted )
Nev ( Voted )
Duncanh ( Voted )
j1mbrown ( Voted )
gregmcateer ( No entry photos )
woodspoiler ( Voted )
HudsonCarpentry ( Voted )
MonkeyBiter ( Voted )
Haldane ( Voted )
Dennisk ( Voted )
Blister ( Voted )
Silverbirch ( Voted )


Plus Richard Findley ( Voted )

I have noticed that some entry's are not within the rules

Please remember you are not able to vote for yourself :mrgreen:

 

[duncanh]

I have noticed that some entry's are not within the rules

Strictly speaking, the challenge text didn't specifically say that colour, pyrography, material or twigs were allowed, but that would discount the majority of the entries and leave me with only 3 to vote from...

 

[nev]

dont forget theres a roundup page here to make choosing a bit easier
http://www.quest42.co.uk/woodwork/forum/dec2011.htm

 

[Blister]

I have noticed that some entry's are not within the rules

Strictly speaking, the challenge text didn't specifically say that colour, pyrography, material or twigs were allowed, but that would discount the majority of the entries and leave me with only 3 to vote from...

Agreed , but it did say

" To create a Christmas related item

This can be a Snowman ( Snowperson :lol: ) a Christmas tree or group of items making a scene
Must be as festive as possible

Max diameter of 12”
Max height 12”
Any wood type
Must be lathe turned
Also allowed are , cotton wool, tinsel and glitter to enhance your entry ( But you must still be able to see that its made from wood :wink: "

So I cant see anything re paint pyro carving texturing piercing in the above requirements

Happy Xmas to one and all :deer :ho2 :deer

 

[Hudson Carpentry]

Don't say you can't either

 

[dennisk]

1 Silverbirch, just great stuff. Well thought out with a good sense of scale.
2 Monkeybiter, loved the grouping and they way they all looked up to the angel.
3 Haldane, once again great stuff. I always look forward to his stuff.
4 Woodspoiler, nice group.
5 Duncanh, my favourite piece technically.

 

[Melinda_dd]

Thanks for sharing your votes :?

 

[dennisk]

Sorry everyone, I screwed up.

 

[Blister]

Can the last 5 please PM me you votes

Thanks

 

[Blister]

j1mbrown

Can you please PM me you top 5 so I can complete the scores for December

If no pm arrives by 18.00 today j1mbrown will not be included in the scores as I need to complete this tonight

 

[Blister]

All votes are now in

Will do the results later tonight