Grawschbags
Established Member
paulrockliffe":1m1z0qkt said:
Definitely will be looking in to this when I get a table saw, and see what my space looks like.
Single Garage Workshop - Table Saw dilema...
- Thread starter Grawschbags
- Start date
Help Support UKworkshop.co.uk:
Definitely will be looking in to this when I get a table saw, and see what my space looks like.
Butch
New member
Dear single garage
As was already asked, what you are going to be cutting is what is important in making this decision . Some of the new track saws are indeed great for making many of the cuts you can make on a table saw but not all of the cuts that are possible on the table saw. . Many other types of cuts which I will call craftsman or journey cuts can be made with a table saw. If you are only cutting panels of one type of another all you may need is a track saw . They are also making some great panel saws in smaller sizes now which are much less costly than a good track saw. Both of those options would take up much less space and could still get the job done. If cost is what you are looking to keep down then I believe you could get a full size table saw for less than a top of the line track saw. This is the case here in America at least in my opinion, because there is only one brand of track saw to buy and by the time you get the necessary tables , different sizes of tracks , clamps and all the rest that you will be needing you will have more than what is needed to purchase one of many very good table saws sold in America. Don't think I am saying that track saws are not necessary or worth the cost or that they can not replace a table saw in some situations , because they could ! I came very close to getting one for myself due to work space , so far it is simply the cost that is stopping me from making the switch. I did not know anything about the saw you are talking about so I looked it up on the Internet . I was very impressed it looks like it could be a great saw, the sliding table for myself would be a must as would all the side and rear tables. Remember that you may be able to make the right side table to do double duty and make your router table part of it and save some space. Many people are making this type of router table and you may be able to as well. I myself would try very hard to make space for the table saw unless I was just cutting panels . I guess I should say what I mean when I said there is only one brand of track saw , what I mean is in my opinion there is only one.. I know we all have opinions and mine is simply that , mine . Sorry this is so long I was in the Air Force and had to cover everything. If I can be any help at all just let me know. My name is Butch.
As was already asked, what you are going to be cutting is what is important in making this decision . Some of the new track saws are indeed great for making many of the cuts you can make on a table saw but not all of the cuts that are possible on the table saw. . Many other types of cuts which I will call craftsman or journey cuts can be made with a table saw. If you are only cutting panels of one type of another all you may need is a track saw . They are also making some great panel saws in smaller sizes now which are much less costly than a good track saw. Both of those options would take up much less space and could still get the job done. If cost is what you are looking to keep down then I believe you could get a full size table saw for less than a top of the line track saw. This is the case here in America at least in my opinion, because there is only one brand of track saw to buy and by the time you get the necessary tables , different sizes of tracks , clamps and all the rest that you will be needing you will have more than what is needed to purchase one of many very good table saws sold in America. Don't think I am saying that track saws are not necessary or worth the cost or that they can not replace a table saw in some situations , because they could ! I came very close to getting one for myself due to work space , so far it is simply the cost that is stopping me from making the switch. I did not know anything about the saw you are talking about so I looked it up on the Internet . I was very impressed it looks like it could be a great saw, the sliding table for myself would be a must as would all the side and rear tables. Remember that you may be able to make the right side table to do double duty and make your router table part of it and save some space. Many people are making this type of router table and you may be able to as well. I myself would try very hard to make space for the table saw unless I was just cutting panels . I guess I should say what I mean when I said there is only one brand of track saw , what I mean is in my opinion there is only one.. I know we all have opinions and mine is simply that , mine . Sorry this is so long I was in the Air Force and had to cover everything. If I can be any help at all just let me know. My name is Butch.
SammyQ
Established Member
You WHAT?? :shock: :shock: :shock: Bandsaws are THE way of retaining ripping capacity without the acreage of a table saw! Sure, cross cuts are tricky mid-board with a B/S, but hand-held circular saws are not that difficult to manoever and indeed at least one 'pro' I know simply uses a big butch Elu jig saw!
Sam
Bodgers
Established Member
Butch":2bhugtym said:
Unfortunately, that is not the case in Europe. A cheap full size (i.e. Not site saw) table saw with induction motor etc is going to start at about around £600 in Europe/UK. That is already above Festool tracksaw level.
This probably has something to do with the fact that full size table saws don't sell as well at consumer level in the UK/Europe because we have sheds and small single garages for workshops
custard
Established Member
Bodgers":b3uay78s said:
You can't have read my post properly Bodgers, I pretty much say the exact opposite of that!
I say I spent many years seriously making hardwood furniture in a single garage sized space, but with only a couple of basic machines and a simple set of hand tools!
This user was talking about both machines in a single garage. In my joinery workshop I use my table saw more than any other single piece of kit, so for me, chosing between the two is a no brainer. I have a small 14" bandsaw which I mostly use for some scrolling, small batch tenoning and cutting out turning blanks but my bench saw is my go to saw of choice. Each to his ownSammyQ":1lrpzbmu said:
LancsRick
Established Member
I love my RAS . Although I'll readily admit that ripping is a damn sight easier on the TS.
. Although I'll readily admit that ripping is a damn sight easier on the TS.
user22161
Established Member
Had the same problem as many here, working in a single garage designed for 1980s width cars. SWMBO finally agreed to extension as long as it wasn't too big and dominated the garden. Came up with one sided job which cost < £2k as trusses didn't need replacing, used an RSJ to span where old wall plate was, floor area now 17' x 14'. All tools (TS, BS,PT etc.) are on mobile bases so I can push them to one side and still get the car in when we're away. May be worth considering for some?
Attachments
Hi Graeme,
I am also in central Scotland and working from a single garage, building furniture for my own benefit as I have a full time job and it is just a hobby to keep me sane. I started with a larger bandsaw and built my first item, a single cabin bed for my son with only this, a workbench and hand tools. Progressively I have added a Sedgwick Planer thicknesser and I am still rebuilding a small Startrite Ta145 saw. I have posted on some of this elsewhere on this forum including building mobile bases. I have been lucky to acquire a lot of kit secondhand but also bought new with a Festool TS55, replacing a similar DeWalt track saw. I don't think I can add much else to whats been said, it depends what you are building. Personally, the track saw has proved invaluable but there are some jobs that it's not suited to hence I will be completing my table saw refurb this year.
I am out of the country this week on business but when I get back I will post some photos of my single garage workshop. It's probably true that a larger workshop would be even better but I console myself in the knowledge that some people are turning out much better things than me in a lot less space.
Best regards
Nigel
Photos added 14/01/2017, shown clockwise from door
Garage view from front
Minimax S45 Bandsaw
Tool Cabinet
Workbench
Mitre saw
Chip extractor & Mortice
Planer Thicknesser
Table Saw (still being rebuilt)
Dust Filter
Wood storage (in 4 locations)
I am also in central Scotland and working from a single garage, building furniture for my own benefit as I have a full time job and it is just a hobby to keep me sane. I started with a larger bandsaw and built my first item, a single cabin bed for my son with only this, a workbench and hand tools. Progressively I have added a Sedgwick Planer thicknesser and I am still rebuilding a small Startrite Ta145 saw. I have posted on some of this elsewhere on this forum including building mobile bases. I have been lucky to acquire a lot of kit secondhand but also bought new with a Festool TS55, replacing a similar DeWalt track saw. I don't think I can add much else to whats been said, it depends what you are building. Personally, the track saw has proved invaluable but there are some jobs that it's not suited to hence I will be completing my table saw refurb this year.
I am out of the country this week on business but when I get back I will post some photos of my single garage workshop. It's probably true that a larger workshop would be even better but I console myself in the knowledge that some people are turning out much better things than me in a lot less space.
Best regards
Nigel
Photos added 14/01/2017, shown clockwise from door
Garage view from front
Minimax S45 Bandsaw
Tool Cabinet
Workbench
Mitre saw
Chip extractor & Mortice
Planer Thicknesser
Table Saw (still being rebuilt)
Dust Filter
Wood storage (in 4 locations)
Attachments
Grawschbags
Established Member
ndbrown":1k8x8you said:
Thanks for the response Nigel. Sounds as though you use your space for the same purposes that I will be. As I mentioned earlier, mine is purely for hobby use as well.
I don't deny that a track saw is a valuable tool, just that I see me getting far more use from a table saw. In an ideal world I'd have both... :mrgreen:
Would be really interested to see your pictures, and how you've used your space.
Ps... I see from your profile that you're located in Dunfermline. I work in Dunfermline, travelling from Bathgate.
Hi Graeme,
Uploaded my photos to the previous post now. I would describe it as a galley style layout but almost everything on the floor is mobile. Glad I went for separates as I had originally considered a universal machine and I now realise that it would not have worked out for me.
Nigel
Uploaded my photos to the previous post now. I would describe it as a galley style layout but almost everything on the floor is mobile. Glad I went for separates as I had originally considered a universal machine and I now realise that it would not have worked out for me.
Nigel
Grawschbags
Established Member
Thanks very much for taking the time to upload the pictures, Nigel.ndbrown":116xrv0z said:
Looks like a great use of the space you have. Not much spare by the looks of it... I get the impression I could accommodate a more dedicated table saw, based on your layout.
Going off on a tangent, how do you find the lighting in the garage with the strip lights running down the centre? I'm currently giving some thought to lighting, either strips or LED panels.
Graeme
I have had the strip lights for a long time now, high frequency ones with daylight tubes in the front one at the bench. I have not experienced any issues with shadows at working height although higher up just under the wood racks, there is a little bit of shadowing. Things have moved on a lot since I got these, so I would probably look around at LED as well. For me, it's painful to say it but as I get a bit older, I appreciate plenty of light!
In the better weather or at least what passes for better weather in Scotland, I generally have garage door open anyway.
Nigel
In the better weather or at least what passes for better weather in Scotland, I generally have garage door open anyway.
Nigel
