henton49er
Established Member
Richard has done his judging and I have been compiling the entrants' and overall scoring :shock: , so here are the results of February's woodturning challenge - a fisherman's priest.
Judges Scoring:
Richard's comments and scores allocated [by me]:-
Well done to all the entrants. Nice to see so many this month and a very wide range of interpretations of the brief.
1st Nev. Really well turned and finished and a classic shape. Well done. [10 points]
2nd SheptonPhil. Another classic design really well executed. Good choice of timber which may not have been simple to turn. Great result. [8 points]
3rd Sammo. A less classic design which has grown on me over the last few days that I have been looking in on this thread. Well turned and finished. Good work. [6 points]
4th HeatherW. A really simple design but well executed. [4 points]
5th Random Orbit Bob. A high standard of finishing and good timber choice. There is a slight evidence of a centre mark on the handle which got this entry marked down. I thought it was an interesting choice of shape, being concave on the striking face but I guess it should still do the job (you know better than me as you are the fisherman!) [2 points]
All other entrants get one point each.
Well done all. Keep up the good work
Entrants' Scores
10 of the 12 entrants sent me their choices for the top three entries.
SheptonPhil came out on top with his score including 5 first places [5 points]
Randon Orbital Bob came second, with three first places in his overall score [4 points]
Woodmonkey and nev came joint third [3 points each]
Sammo and tpot came joint fifth [1 point each]
Overall Scoring
In joint first place were nev and SheptonPhil on 13 points, with nev winning the plaque by virtue of his higher Judges score. Well done to you both!! =D> =D> =D> =D> =D>
In third place was sammo with 7 points
In fourth place was Random Orbital Bob with 6 points
In joint fifth place were Woodmonkey and Heatherw with 4 points each.
[It's taking me longer to work out the scoring than it does to turn an entry
I think my brain must be slowing down :shock: :shock: !!]
Scores to Date
heatherw 18
nev 15
Dalboy 14
Sheptonphil 14
Random Orbital Bob 12
sammo 10
tpot 6
procell 5
Dennisk 4
woodmonkey 4
Soylent1 3
winemaker 2
jethro 1
Melinda_dd 1
Judges Scoring:
Richard's comments and scores allocated [by me]:-
Well done to all the entrants. Nice to see so many this month and a very wide range of interpretations of the brief.
1st Nev. Really well turned and finished and a classic shape. Well done. [10 points]
2nd SheptonPhil. Another classic design really well executed. Good choice of timber which may not have been simple to turn. Great result. [8 points]
3rd Sammo. A less classic design which has grown on me over the last few days that I have been looking in on this thread. Well turned and finished. Good work. [6 points]
4th HeatherW. A really simple design but well executed. [4 points]
5th Random Orbit Bob. A high standard of finishing and good timber choice. There is a slight evidence of a centre mark on the handle which got this entry marked down. I thought it was an interesting choice of shape, being concave on the striking face but I guess it should still do the job (you know better than me as you are the fisherman!) [2 points]
All other entrants get one point each.
Well done all. Keep up the good work
Entrants' Scores
10 of the 12 entrants sent me their choices for the top three entries.
SheptonPhil came out on top with his score including 5 first places [5 points]
Randon Orbital Bob came second, with three first places in his overall score [4 points]
Woodmonkey and nev came joint third [3 points each]
Sammo and tpot came joint fifth [1 point each]
Overall Scoring
In joint first place were nev and SheptonPhil on 13 points, with nev winning the plaque by virtue of his higher Judges score. Well done to you both!! =D> =D> =D> =D> =D>
In third place was sammo with 7 points
In fourth place was Random Orbital Bob with 6 points
In joint fifth place were Woodmonkey and Heatherw with 4 points each.
[It's taking me longer to work out the scoring than it does to turn an entry
I think my brain must be slowing down :shock: :shock: !!]Scores to Date
heatherw 18
nev 15
Dalboy 14
Sheptonphil 14
Random Orbital Bob 12
sammo 10
tpot 6
procell 5
Dennisk 4
woodmonkey 4
Soylent1 3
winemaker 2
jethro 1
Melinda_dd 1
