Beach bowl?

UKworkshop.co.uk

Help Support UKworkshop.co.uk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

gaz8521

Established Member
Joined
31 Oct 2007
Messages
59
Reaction score
0
Location
Ellesmere port
haven't posted for a while so I thought I'd put this on and see what you all think.It's beach I think, cut from a log I got back in March. I think it's almost dry now so I thought I would finish it,still expecting it to move a bit when it comes indoors.So it's 270 dia by 130 high with all thickness of about 20.So what do you think?


It's finished with wax and then buffed.
 
Hi,

I normally prefer curved sides, but that is nice, the waxed sheen is lovely,

ps - i had a look at your photobucket, i love your other rimmed bowls !

Loz
 
I would say you're designation of Beech is correct, personally I prefer thinner walled items but having said that your 20mm does not seem out of place with the overall proportions.

Trying not to turn my comments into a critique, but a personal observation based on your selection of angular form, the top inner edge is showing a slight rounding and could be construed as sanding blending, keeping a sharper edge shouts better control of form to me.

Alternate is to form inner edge into a distinct 'bugle mouth' curve which will maintain the weight of the item but give the impression of a thinner wall.
 
Thats a nice bowl Gaz, A pleasing shape, as said !
I like the taper of the rim, back in towards the inside of the bowl, rather than it just being 'square', if you get my meaning.

Looks like a good finish on it too, with no nasty evidence of 'tools contact', and the wax finish thats been applied looks just right 8)

From the photo, its more 'chocolaty' than most of the beech I've tried, and that in itself, is very appealing.

Very nice ! :) :) 8)
 
Hi Gaz,

Like Chas I would probably go for slightly thinner walls but the shape is good. These "simple" shapes are often the hardest to do well and the curve on the outside is really good.

I agree that it looks like Beech. A good bit too!

Richard
 
Thanks for all your comment's.I did think about putting a slight curve on the sides but decided against it for no reason(I think it just looks better ) It did have a sharp inner edge, but again I think the shape flows better with a chamfer.




And Loz do you mean these two.
their both yew with mahogany rims finished in wax again.I think the rim on the smaller one is a bit too deep and the finish isn't great but I'm going to put back on the lathe and wax it again.in the mean time thanks again for the comments and I'll try not to leave so long this time
 
Oooh - very nice :D

To me,the second one looks better proportioned in terms of the rim.Very light coloured for yew,isn't it ?All the yew I've had (and got),the heartwood was definitely orange,some with purple staining.

Andrew
 
Thanks again for the comments and yes I agree with you both they are a bit pale for 'yew'? So if their not yew what do you think they are?
 
So what do you think Loz is it 'yew' or not.not too sure myself,I got the wood off the side of the road(think the council cut it down and it made it wa back to my place).Thought it was yew because of the difference in the heart and the sap wood but now i'm not so sure.And thanks for the comments I also think it is the better of the two
 
I like them both - I prefer the thinner depth of mahogany on the second one but the foot looks too deep and perhaps a tad wide for my liking (hope you don't mind that comment, obviously it's down to personal preference).

I'd also say the the wood definitely isn't yew.
If the wood had bark on was it kind of scaly and look like this ?

Duncan
 
gaz8521":l2tuljr9 said:
So what do you think Loz is it 'yew' or not.not too sure myself,I got the wood off the side of the road(think the council cut it down and it made it wa back to my place).Thought it was yew because of the difference in the heart and the sap wood but now i'm not so sure.And thanks for the comments I also think it is the better of the two

I can't see the council cutting down a Yew, and i've very rarely seen Yews outside of arboretums or church yards ! - not normally something you see in modern gardens - or the side of the road !!!!

was there any bark/foliage around the wood to help id ?
 
loz":34vd9k8e said:
I can't see the council cutting down a Yew, and i've very rarely seen Yews outside of arboretums or church yards ! - not normally something you see in modern gardens - or the side of the road !!!!

The farm house next door to where I grew up had a large yew tree in the orchard. Fantastic for climbing :D
 
duncanh":mdu8tipp said:
loz":mdu8tipp said:
I can't see the council cutting down a Yew, and i've very rarely seen Yews outside of arboretums or church yards ! - not normally something you see in modern gardens - or the side of the road !!!!

The farm house next door to where I grew up had a large yew tree in the orchard. Fantastic for climbing :D
i bet it was there before the farm was though ;-)
 
There's an old Yew in the village of Pencaitland, just outside of Edinburgh, and its said that it knows all of Scotland's secrets, both past and future.
The Battlefield Band sang about it ( amongst others ), and here is its 'story'.
Its not a very 'technical' thing to post, but I just liked the whole tale...
the idea of a majestic wise old tree watching over the country just appealed. ! :wink:

A mile frae Pentcaitland, on the road to the sea
Stands a yew tree a thousand years old
And the old women swear by the grey o' their hair
That it knows what the future will hold
For the shadows of Scotland stand round it
'Mid the kail and the corn and the kye
All the hopes and the fears of a thousand long years
Under the Lothian sky

Did you look through the haze o' the lang summer days
Tae the South and the far English border
A' the bonnets o' steel on Flodden's far field
Did they march by your side in good order
Did you ask them the price o' their glory
When you heard the great slaughter begin
For the dust o' their bones would rise up from the stones
To bring tears to the eyes o' the wind

Not once did you speak for the poor and the weak
When the moss-strippers lay in your shade
To count out the plunder and hide frae the thunder
And share out the spoils o' their raid
But you saw the smiles o' the gentry
And the laughter of lords at their gains
When the poor hunt the poor across mountain and moor
The rich man can keep them in chains

Did you no' think tae tell when John Knox himsel'
Preached under your branches sae black
To the poor common folk who would lift up the yoke
O' the bishops and priests frae their backs
But you knew the bargain he sold them
And freedom was only one part
For the price o' their souls was a gospel sae cold
It would freeze up the joy in their hearts

And I thought as I stood and laid hands on your wood
That it might be a kindness to fell you
One kiss o' the axe and you're freed frae the racks
O' the sad bloody tales that men tell you
But a wee bird flew out from your branches
And sang out as never before
And the words o' the song were a thousand years long
And to learn them's a long thousand more
 
Loz wrote
I can't see the council cutting down a Yew,
Close to where we live is a shopping area called The Yew Tree
Named due to there being an old Yew Tree that was growing their,until a few years ago when the council decided to change the road layout their.
And yes you guessed it the workers mistakenly :roll: cut the old Yew down.
It as since been replaced but it is nothing like the old Yew :(
 
Back
Top