I have the results for the January Bowl Challenge
Judged by Paul , Thanks Paul =D>
1st 6 points Boysie39
A simple understated curve with a slight reverse curve at the foot to lift the bowl. The chuck spigot was removed/reshaped rather than being left in. The angled inner rim leads the eye into the bowl and gives a lighter feel to the bowl. Nicely finished and well turned.
2nd 5 points Jumps
The ogee isn't always easy to get right but this one worked. Good proportions, removed/reshaped chuck spigot at the base. The foot size looks balanced with the bowl.
3rd 4 points Silverbirch
A well proportioned bowl with a nice simple detail around the inner rim to delineate the transition from bowl to rim. Nicely finished.
4th 3 points and Highly commended Hesh
Another good example of an ogee where the curve flows reasonably well. The foot lifts the bowl and allows the curve at the base to flow right through.
5th 2 points and Highly commended Cambournepete
A simple, well proportioned design with a flowing curve. The base shows the chuck spigot/recess was removed/reshaped. Nicely finished.
All other entrants get 1 point
Further Judges comments :-
Some general observations - Leaving the chuck recess or spigot generally leads to a thicker base than would otherwise be necessary and it adds nothing to the appeal so it's best removed (at least one entry would have been in the top 5 had they done this). Don't be afraid to take of as much wood as necessary to achieve a pleasing shape. Pay attention to balancing different sections and elements so they work together rather than competing. Finally, to help with judging, try to take the photos filling the frame with the item.
Well done to everyone involved and thank you for taking part and supporting the 2012 challenge
I will by 1st Feb complete the rules and requirements for the Suspended Ball challenge , to be judged by Richard
Judged by Paul , Thanks Paul =D>
1st 6 points Boysie39
A simple understated curve with a slight reverse curve at the foot to lift the bowl. The chuck spigot was removed/reshaped rather than being left in. The angled inner rim leads the eye into the bowl and gives a lighter feel to the bowl. Nicely finished and well turned.
2nd 5 points Jumps
The ogee isn't always easy to get right but this one worked. Good proportions, removed/reshaped chuck spigot at the base. The foot size looks balanced with the bowl.
3rd 4 points Silverbirch
A well proportioned bowl with a nice simple detail around the inner rim to delineate the transition from bowl to rim. Nicely finished.
4th 3 points and Highly commended Hesh
Another good example of an ogee where the curve flows reasonably well. The foot lifts the bowl and allows the curve at the base to flow right through.
5th 2 points and Highly commended Cambournepete
A simple, well proportioned design with a flowing curve. The base shows the chuck spigot/recess was removed/reshaped. Nicely finished.
All other entrants get 1 point
Further Judges comments :-
Some general observations - Leaving the chuck recess or spigot generally leads to a thicker base than would otherwise be necessary and it adds nothing to the appeal so it's best removed (at least one entry would have been in the top 5 had they done this). Don't be afraid to take of as much wood as necessary to achieve a pleasing shape. Pay attention to balancing different sections and elements so they work together rather than competing. Finally, to help with judging, try to take the photos filling the frame with the item.
Well done to everyone involved and thank you for taking part and supporting the 2012 challenge
I will by 1st Feb complete the rules and requirements for the Suspended Ball challenge , to be judged by Richard
