Tenon Saws - features

UKworkshop.co.uk

Help Support UKworkshop.co.uk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Gary_S

Established Member
Joined
25 Jun 2015
Messages
110
Reaction score
30
Location
Marlborough
The price range of tenon saws is quite wide. I want to use hand tools as well as machine tools and this is one that I want to get right for things like dovetails. What should I look for in a good tenon saw and what sort of price range?
 
If you're just getting into hand work, it's probably best to avoid secondhand saws. They will almost certainly be blunt, and quite possibly bent as well. Later, as you develop, you may enjoy the challenge of refurbishing old saws, and that could eventually give you some exceptionally good tools. However, it's better to learn how to saw before learning saw sharpening.

With that in mind, there are several options. It may be worth buying a hardpoint backsaw from one of the sheds as a first saw. Reasons - it'll be pretty cheap compared to new 'nice' saws, but more importantly it'll be straight and sharp, and will keep it's sharpness for a fair while. Try to find one with a fairly heavy back if you can; the weight helps the saw do the work. Handles are a matter of personal taste, but find a comfortable one. Thus, you can concentrate on developing sawing skills knowing that the tool is adequate, if not all that aesthetically pleasing.

Later, if you wish, you can supplement the kit with some nicer saws, new or vintage (for refurbishment). Most people tend to have a small one for dovetails, and maybe one or two larger ones for cross-cutting on the bench and for tenon cheeks. (Some people accumulate far more than that, though - beware! Saving neglected vintage saws can become addictive....)
 
The Veritas dovetail saws are very good and not overly expensive if you shop around.
 
Jacob":18iedg8z said:
Ebay - Old Spear & Jackson 12 or 14" good one about £30 but may be cheaper, modern handles - not curly ones unless cheap.
Or new one like this
Plenty of blade on like this one
Not worn out like this one

PS for dovetails you want a dovetail saw - much as above but 8"

None of the linked saw is sharp/ready to use. Very bad for any beginner.

Before you start to sharpen saws you should reallxy have one saw wich saws like it should. Veritas is the best Value/Price, though the design is not for everybody.

Cheers
Pedder
 
Cheshirechappie":crw7einq said:
If you're just getting into hand work, it's probably best to avoid secondhand saws. They will almost certainly be blunt, ...
In which case you take it to your local saw doctor. There will be one near you - ask around.
We live in a time in which second hand woodwork tools are two a penny. No need to buy new.
If you buy new and actually use it it will need sharpening soon enough - then it might as well have been a second hand cheapo.
A saw is as good as it's last sharpening.
 
MMUK":7koy80ng said:
For starting out you may find it easier using a half decent hardpoint saw like a Bahco :)
I'm loving my recent purchase of a Stanley jet cut 15" toolbox saw. I had to put it down yesterday cause I thought it'd be sad if it went blunt when I could be using my 22 inch jet cut. - problem solved a few minutes later. £21.50 delivered for 5, which now means I've got 9 of em ! my workmates kid took one on and he seems to be getting on with it really well.
64896233f70866b36bd2716f9921801a.jpg


Sent from my SM-G900F using Tapatalk
 
Thanks for all of the advice. My uncle owns a saw sharpening company in London but alas they do machine saws for furniture makers etc. I love the look of the old ones but will get a new inexpensive one to start. I know the dangers of loving antique implements. I have more fly boxes (fishing) than any man could use but they are so pretty lol.
 
Paul Chapman":3mcj1wpw said:
Jacob":3mcj1wpw said:
In which case you take it to your local saw doctor. There will be one near you

Are you spreading myths again, Jacob?

Cheers :wink:

Paul

There's a local one in Sheffield called Thomas Flinn. Reasonable charge for sharpening but unfortunately that changes considerably if you have to use postal services. If you have 4 or 5 saws to sharpen, at any one time, then I guess the postage is much less of a factor.
 
Back
Top