Keep popping back to these two Pete, could not get my head round what my reaction was all about.
Out of the two I prefer the Sycamore, well formed contour including the lip bead, no sanding flats that I can see, just wondering if a flatter wider collar (a la George) would give an impression of a thinner wall on the vessel.
Guess the Oak was the one that 'was not going to beat you' on the hard work front, slight impression that the wood blank dictated the shape with that one I'm afraid, and the finial followed the body theme.
Chas in 'Grumpy old man mode' this morning.