• We invite you to join UKWorkshop.
    Members can turn off viewing Ads!

What do you think to the latest GWW?

UKworkshop.co.uk

Help Support UKworkshop.co.uk:

MikeW

Established Member
Joined
15 Apr 2005
Messages
1,933
Reaction score
0
Location
Forest Grove, Oregon USA
Ok, you tempted me out of hiding...but I really am gonna hide this time :lol:

Alf":3glvduk4 said:
MikeW":3glvduk4 said:
FWW began as a magazine about the craft of woodworking aimed at the existing readership. The readership back then was primarily people who made a portion or all of their money from the craft...
So if what they were doing for their readership before wasn't what people wanted to read, why did all those people start reading it in the first place and change the demographic...? :-k
Cheers, Alf
Oh now now...you didn't quote me fully to the point. The point I was trying to make and went on to say in the paragraph following the one you did quote was that over time it began to change.

I think they were giving the general readership what they wanted. (Even in some of the earliest issues I have (late 1970s, subscription began mid 1980s) there were occassionally people who wanted it less "dumbed down.")

Beginning in the 1970s when woodworking once again was picking up in popularity among non-professionals there was little else to subscribe to--and no internet.

Over time an ever larger subscriber base was comprised of people who wanted to learn the craft, ww schools were just picking up steam in the late 70s to early 80s and there we not many of them.

Manufacturers began targeting this growing base of hobbists and began making equipment aimed at this market, their advertising began to change to reflect this. Compare the 1970s advertising of say Powermatic to their ads in the mid-80s where they specifically designed an ad campaign saying they were "focusing their engineering expertise and resources for the craftsman, contractor and hobbyist" and "Responding to your expressed needs," emphasis is in their ad.

All of this shift in target audience took over a decade. But you can see it in FWW, from the articles, to advertisers, to the questions column--heck, even the tips column became fairly recycled.

But the real question for GWW is who is the target audience? If comprised of more than one demographic or skill level reader (most likely and probably should, let alone have to) what is or will be the company's goal in article content/skill level to meet this readership mix? Will its advertising department be able to sell this company philosophy to the advertisers? Will it be able to attract enough interest among authors who will support the company's vision and goals?

Whatever the answers to the above issues and those I don't even know to mention, GWW will change over time as it sees need to. This will please some and disapoint others.

Personally I wish GWW the best. In part because it seems, especially by their presence on this public forum, they care. Also in part because by becoming involved in this forum I have a vested interest in some authors who frequent here, and wish them continued success and personal fulfillment in their endeavors.
 

Pete W

Established Member
Joined
31 Jan 2004
Messages
911
Reaction score
0
Location
London UK
Nick Gibbs":1zyqafjr said:
Much of what Pete W says is absolutely right, but he's wrong about the adverts for other magazines in Good Wood.
Ah well, that's better than my usual win-loss ratio :).

I'm looking forward to seeing what changes await in the next issue. Perhaps we can re-run this thread when all has been revealed?
 

simuk

Established Member
Joined
22 May 2003
Messages
141
Reaction score
0
Location
portsmouth, UK
Have been browsing & through woodworking mags for a couple of years looking for projects that i could make. And in that time i have only ever found one project thats motivated me to make it.

Books that i have bought, there has maybe one or two projects that i have considered .
Most of the projects that i have made are from images that i have seen on the internet or from my own desighn. If i need info on a particular woodworking subject then i just surf the internet after searching this forum first to get the answers or pick up a book.
I enjoy the tip sections in mags but this is always a small page

If i am considering buying a tools or machinery then i will surf the internet for reviews and ask on on forums as i am aware of the possibility that mags could be influenced by manfactuers paying for advertising space.

Simuk
 
Top