Timber Selection

UKworkshop.co.uk

Help Support UKworkshop.co.uk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

custard

Established Member
Joined
20 Aug 2008
Messages
7,170
Reaction score
672
Location
Hampshire
Andy T was in my workshop yesterday and we got talking about selecting boards for specific furniture components, it's a dimension of furniture making that often gets ignored but is actually one of the key features that separates an individually made piece from the factory made stuff from Oak Furnitureland, where any old component gets attached to any other component with no thought or care.

Here's the piece we were discussing,

Shkr-Cab-Board-Section-1.jpg


It's a Shaker style cabinet on cabinet made from Curly Cherry. There's nothing special about the build, I'd like to think it's well made, but at the end of the day it's just basic, rectilinear furniture making. What justifies the premium is that it's largely hand built, from solid timber, with all the traditionally cabinet making details, and most importantly that it uses highly figured boards of Curly Cherry that will result in a piece that has an almost holographic shimmer once finished.

To my eye one of the shortcomings of much Shaker design is the usual absence of a cornice. The client insisted on it here as well so that's a given. But it still leaves the problem of how to stop the eye just drifting upwards and disappearing out from the top of the cabinet, because there's nothing there to hold their attention. One solution could be to try and turn the drawers, which are at the bottom of the upper cabinet, into the focal point?

To try and do that amidst a sea of highly figured timbers isn't easy, but one thing that might help is if the drawers featured a distinctive grain patterns that ran seamlessly across all the drawer fronts? Picking through the boards I found this,

Shkr-Cab-Board-Selection-2.jpg


Maybe this would help hold the eye in this particular location?

There's no right or wrong answers, it's just a small example of the furniture maker trying to squeeze every last drop out of the timber's potential. Incidentally, you can see how the panels that have been fitted also run consecutively from the same board, and all the boards came from the same tree so when finished the piece will be very integrated and harmonious in colour and tone. None of this is about cabinet making skill per se, but it's still important in producing something that's worth having.
 

Attachments

  • Shkr-Cab-Board-Section-1.jpg
    Shkr-Cab-Board-Section-1.jpg
    86.3 KB
  • Shkr-Cab-Board-Selection-2.jpg
    Shkr-Cab-Board-Selection-2.jpg
    68.4 KB
It looks nice but I find once the you have devisions it takes a trained eye to even notice continuation of the grain unless very prominent. On the other hand careless selection sticks out like a sore thumb. What are the handles? I would look at these to draw the eye with the grain as you have selected.

I am no designer so glad there are no right or wrong answers :D
 
Beau":29h1s6uf said:
It looks nice but I find once the you have devisions it takes a trained eye to even notice continuation of the grain unless very prominent. On the other hand careless selection sticks out like a sore thumb. What are the handles? I would look at these to draw the eye with the grain as you have selected.

I am no designer so glad there are no right or wrong answers :D

Good points, incidentally I'm no designer either but if you make furniture then you don't get a choice, you have to be a designer!

Drawer pulls are bog standard Shaker style, I did suggest to the client that I turned them in Ebony or African Blackwood, but they vetoed that and said they wanted "authentic" timbers (so the back is panelled in American Tulipwood and the drawer runners are White Oak even though I'd have usually clad the runners with a 3mm veneer of Rosewood to make them more slick and harder wearing).
 
" I did suggest to the client that I turned them in Ebony or African Blackwood, but they vetoed that "

Shame. Think that would be just the ticket. Small but dark.
 
Unfortunately clients are often the biggest obstacle between a beautiful design and an unfortunate compromise.
Its often a difficult line to walk, you want to steer the customer towards what you know (or think) will produce the best result but everyone is different and 10 different customers will give you 10 different alternatives they prefer (probably all of which you baulk at :p )

I spend a vast amount of time trying to convince customers to not put awful ideas into the designs, some things work and plainly some really don't.

Anyway I digress, love the cabinet custard, shame the client is curtailing your creativity somewhat. I also think some dark handles would be a nice touch. They wouldn't accept the same timber, but stained to give it a little more impact?
 
Another related point that I can't recall seeing explicitly stated very often is that to make really special pieces of furniture, you have to be prepared to cut wood for effect, not economy.

So cutting those three little drawer fronts out of that lovely board is the right thing to do.

Clearly, the rest of the board can be used for parts that aren't on show so much, but unless you also make tiny boxes and a lot of turned trinkets, quite a high percentage of waste is going to be part of the overall picture. It makes sense for this sort of piece, where the materials cost is relatively small compared to the hundreds of hours of skilled labour.

And I can confirm that Custard is as skilled and helpful in real life as he is on the forum!
 
OK this is probably heresy but I will throw it out there. I hint of the cherry sap could show on the draws and this would be prominent enough to draw the eye? Now I will get my coat.
 
Beau":rwddx0lv said:
OK this is probably heresy but I will throw it out there. I hint of the cherry sap could show on the draws and this would be prominent enough to draw the eye? Now I will get my coat.

I did something similar with an Oak table top once. The boards were just off the quarter so no medullary rays and also no cathedral grain. Just sweeping slow, undulating curves of grain running the full length of the table. It was destined for a south facing, sunny room overlooking the sea and I wanted a look for the top like sun streaked blonde hair.

After playing around for a while the solution was to retain flashes of sap down the edges of some of the boards. It worked out really well, and although not a complex build it's still one of my favourite pieces.
 
Back
Top