Moose antler with an M42 bandsaw blade without damaging it? Moose, mind not deer - it's much harder.
can I cut ...
- Thread starter Phil Pascoe
- Start date
Help Support UKworkshop.co.uk:
treeturner123
Established Member
I would think it is no problem.
As said, it is only keratin. I use a bandsaw to cut deer antlers fro my small items. Just remember the smell!!!
Phil
As said, it is only keratin. I use a bandsaw to cut deer antlers fro my small items. Just remember the smell!!!
Phil
It isn't keratin, it's bone.
treeturner123
Established Member
The higher the speed the hotter and therefore more smell!!
It doesn't seem to matter what speed from the point of view of the cut itself.
Phil
It doesn't seem to matter what speed from the point of view of the cut itself.
Phil
MikeG.
Established Member
Phil Pascoe":1nqghe0x said:
Are you sure? Every other horn and antler I know of is keratin. I'd be amazed if bone were involved.
According to National Geographic.
Male, or bull, moose grow their antlers each year through the spring and summer. Female moose, called cows, don’t grow antlers. But males’ impressive headgear is made of bone that is an extension of the skull. When they first form, antlers are covered with a layer of skin called velvet, which nourishes the bone as it grows. When finished, the velvet sheds off, a process that the moose often accelerate by rubbing on trees.
Male, or bull, moose grow their antlers each year through the spring and summer. Female moose, called cows, don’t grow antlers. But males’ impressive headgear is made of bone that is an extension of the skull. When they first form, antlers are covered with a layer of skin called velvet, which nourishes the bone as it grows. When finished, the velvet sheds off, a process that the moose often accelerate by rubbing on trees.
I've worked with Deer antler and it seems very bone like, certainly nothing like the various types of horn I have used.
There is a core inside that looks very much like marrow and the outside is very hard and doesn't delaminate like horn.
Aside from the smell it's quite nice to work with though, in fact most of the bone, horn and Ivory I have used is nice to work with, the only thing I didn't like was working with teeth.
There is a core inside that looks very much like marrow and the outside is very hard and doesn't delaminate like horn.
Aside from the smell it's quite nice to work with though, in fact most of the bone, horn and Ivory I have used is nice to work with, the only thing I didn't like was working with teeth.
From what I can gather moose is much denser than deer antler. It's certainly heavier.
I just don't want to destroy a good M42 blade trying it.
I just don't want to destroy a good M42 blade trying it.
MikeG.
Established Member
Bandsaws are used by butchers constantly, for sawing through bones etc. I doubt a bone would be any sort of issue for an M42 blade.
My gast is thoroughly flabbered that moose antler contains bone.
My gast is thoroughly flabbered that moose antler contains bone.
I would think they have a much different tooth formation, though. The saw blades, not the animals. 
Racers
Established Member
- Joined
- 22 Apr 2005
- Messages
- 9,172
- Reaction score
- 127
I found me Puukko thead, you can see the moose antler I cut with the band saw.
puukko-t76004.html?hilit=knife
Pete
puukko-t76004.html?hilit=knife
Pete
According to wikipedia all deer antler are bones, other animals like cows, sheep and goats are keratin. Every day is a school day.
Our dog has antler to chew, they last much longer than other chews or bones. Unfotunately the latest one was particularly big and was damaging the floor when he dropped it so I stuck it through the bandsaw. Worked fine, no obvious change to the blade.
Our dog has antler to chew, they last much longer than other chews or bones. Unfotunately the latest one was particularly big and was damaging the floor when he dropped it so I stuck it through the bandsaw. Worked fine, no obvious change to the blade.
I stalk deer for a living.
All antler is most certainly bone. Amazing to thing that they cast them annually and then regrow them in the space of a couple of months. The next time you see a picture of a gert red stag just think that that bone weighs more than the bone in your legs and it took him two or three months to grow it.
I have provided antler in velvet for stem cell research in the past.
Horn is Keratin, most horned animals don't shed their horns, the only exception I am aware of is the pronghorned antelope. But I don't deal with many horned animals so happy to be corrected on that.
I have cut heaps of antler on a bandsaw. Making beads and keyings and coat hangers etc etc etc. It does smell if it get hot but you get used to it.
As it's round, and inevitably not straight just make sure that you have the antler well secured and braced against the table, the same as you might if you were processing logs or resawing or whatever. Basic bandsaw safety type stuff.
I can tell you from experience if you have been up since 02:30 and decide that afternoon is a good time to sleepily saw up some antler you soon. wake up when you get that sickening bang as the saw grabs the piece you haven't fed correctly. Luckily for me it just bent the blade and didn't remove any of my digits.
All antler is most certainly bone. Amazing to thing that they cast them annually and then regrow them in the space of a couple of months. The next time you see a picture of a gert red stag just think that that bone weighs more than the bone in your legs and it took him two or three months to grow it.
I have provided antler in velvet for stem cell research in the past.
Horn is Keratin, most horned animals don't shed their horns, the only exception I am aware of is the pronghorned antelope. But I don't deal with many horned animals so happy to be corrected on that.
I have cut heaps of antler on a bandsaw. Making beads and keyings and coat hangers etc etc etc. It does smell if it get hot but you get used to it.
As it's round, and inevitably not straight just make sure that you have the antler well secured and braced against the table, the same as you might if you were processing logs or resawing or whatever. Basic bandsaw safety type stuff.
I can tell you from experience if you have been up since 02:30 and decide that afternoon is a good time to sleepily saw up some antler you soon. wake up when you get that sickening bang as the saw grabs the piece you haven't fed correctly. Luckily for me it just bent the blade and didn't remove any of my digits.
