Block Plane for Christmas

UKworkshop.co.uk

Help Support UKworkshop.co.uk:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Mark18PLL

Established Member
Joined
15 Mar 2020
Messages
291
Reaction score
36
Location
Lancashire
Ok so im sending out my Christmas list to Santa (Mrs) and i thought i would put a block plane on it.

Can someone please recommend a half decent (not £200) block plane that is of decent quality please?

thanks in advance and have a great christmas

M
 
You don't need £200. I mainly use Veritas. It's excellent and much cheaper than that. LN and if you want British then Clifton are excellent. The bronze quangsheng ones are also very good (I use one a lot).
 
I have the Lie Nielsen version of this one. Quangsheng Luban No.102 Bronze Apron Plane

I think it is a brilliant bit of kit. Smaller than some block planes but I have never found its size to be an issue. The couple of quengsheng planes that I have are good quality.

Given the issues with postage and stock, vouchers may be a better option at the moment.
 
Another vote for the 102. My most used and favorate plane. - I have full sized block plane(s) but love the way the 102 fits into my hand.
 
I used to have the Lie Nielsen 102 low angle block plane, it was a think of beauty, miss it sometimes, it was incredibly well made, precision engineered for sure, couldn't fault anything about it.
 
I have a Quangsheng low angle block plane, it’s well made, seems to hold an edge and is a pleasure to use.
 
Thanks for the replies. One thing i might have overlooked is a honing kit, its something i don't have a the moment but feel i would need to get at the same time, any recommendations?

Cheers
 
Mine's the very basic Stanley 220, an old one with wooden knob. Light weight is good for a one hander plane. Later ones are heavy and a bit crude.
I've tried a few of the up-market heavy numbers now on offer but they are not for me. Especially those little ones heavy as lead - slip out of your hand and break a toe!
 
Last edited:
In the 50's and 60's a block plane was often the only plane that the home handyman would own. There was a race to the bottom as manufacturers vied with each other to offer the cheapest possible block plane. Consequently, some of the worst hand tools I've ever encountered are these entry level block planes. Stay well clear of them, you might get lucky, more likely it'll be money down the toilet.

Another thing to think about is that block planes get used in lots of different ways. If you plan on using yours like a miniature, one handed plane, used chiefly on long grain for tasks like chamfering or knocking off the arris, then you've got a very wide selection to choose from. Most decent block planes will give you satisfactory service. But if you will chiefly use your block plane for dealing with end grain or for other difficult jobs like cleaning up the edges of plywood, then there's a stronger case for one of the specialist steels like A2 or, even better, the new PM-V11 from Veritas. For most woodworking in temperate zone timbers I'm not entirely convinced of the advantages of these steels, but block planes are often asked to perform at the limits of tool steel resilience, where specialist steels are undoubtedly more useful.

One final point, tools are useless unless you can keep them sharp. But block planes are often awkward tools to sharpen. They're sometimes a bit small to conveniently hand hold, especially if you go for a smaller "apron" style of block plane. And because they're often low angle they need a longer projection from a honing guide, which then introduces more complexity. Veritas are particularly difficult in this respect because they tend to have a tapered blade design, which leaves less material available for side gripping honing guides. There are solutions to all these problems, just be aware of them before you buy.
 
In the 50's and 60's a block plane was often the only plane that the home handyman would own. There was a race to the bottom as manufacturers vied with each other to offer the cheapest possible block plane. Consequently, some of the worst hand tools I've ever encountered are these entry level block planes. Stay well clear of them, you might get lucky, more likely it'll be money down the toilet.

Another thing to think about is that block planes get used in lots of different ways. If you plan on using yours like a miniature, one handed plane, used chiefly on long grain for tasks like chamfering or knocking off the arris, then you've got a very wide selection to choose from. Most decent block planes will give you satisfactory service. But if you will chiefly use your block plane for dealing with end grain or for other difficult jobs like cleaning up the edges of plywood, then there's a stronger case for one of the specialist steels like A2 or, even better, the new PM-V11 from Veritas. For most woodworking in temperate zone timbers I'm not entirely convinced of the advantages of these steels, but block planes are often asked to perform at the limits of tool steel resilience, where specialist steels are undoubtedly more useful.

One final point, tools are useless unless you can keep them sharp. But block planes are often awkward tools to sharpen. They're sometimes a bit small to conveniently hand hold, especially if you go for a smaller "apron" style of block plane. And because they're often low angle they need a longer projection from a honing guide, which then introduces more complexity. Veritas are particularly difficult in this respect because they tend to have a tapered blade design, which leaves less material available for side gripping honing guides. There are solutions to all these problems, just be aware of them before you buy.
My 220 was new about 1975. Basic, but no compromise on quality. Still going strong, on to 3rd blade I think. But yes later Stanleys went steady downhill - I've got a couple of them and they just don't get used.
 
I pimped a modern Stanley low angle block plane. I replaced the iron with a Hock, reversed the front adjustable plate and squared it off to give a tighter adjustment capability and the biggest change was to significantly increase the size of the blade bed. That was done using epoxy. It works as well as my LN version.
IMG_1804.jpeg
 
Thanks for the replies. One thing i might have overlooked is a honing kit, its something i don't have a the moment but feel i would need to get at the same time, any recommendations?

Cheers

Sharpening seems to be an emotive issue, but you asked for recommendations so: a bit of plate glass and some self adhesive sandpaper and a drop of oil works for me. I find a honing guide useful (hurriedly gets coat & leaves).
 
Yeap 3 cheap diamond plates from eBay and a piece of 1000 wet and dry to finish....

I'll join you down the pub!!

Cheers James
 
Veritas are particularly difficult in this respect because they tend to have a tapered blade design, which leaves less material available for side gripping honing guides.
As I discovered when I offered up my eclipse style honing jig to my Veritas low angle blocks blade...quite like this idea on how to get round the taper that defeats my current jig
so think I'll knock one up this week
 
Back
Top